Showing posts with label Wall Street. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wall Street. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

The President’s big speech today

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

If you haven’t had a chance to watch this speech, please do, I’ll wait…otherwise, the transcript is here, helpfully provided by the LA Times.  By way of background, the location of the speech today was a city in Kansas where, 101 years ago, President Theodore Roosevelt gave a speech famously calling for a “New Nationalism” and proposing his “Square Deal” to the American people.  Was President Obama being slightly ambitious in his choice of historical contextualization?  Perhaps, but to my mind it was well worth the risk.

Now then.  While this speech was touted as an “economic” speech, the tenor and content ranged far more widely than simple concepts of supply and demand.  President Obama laid out a new framework for the American economy, with the explicit goal being to rebuild and expand the middle class.  He made the argument that government should not try to “fix” all the problems of society, but that government should work on behalf of the people’s interests.

With a forcefulness that has been heretofore lacking in most of his presidential speeches, President Obama called out greed, irresponsibility, and the continuing fallacy that is “trickle-down economics.”  He called for new rules of the road that apply to everyone, not just to Main Street, but to Wall Street as well.  He defended the Dodd-Frank financial reform bill, and made a stirring statement about the importance of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and its soon-to-be-blocked Director nominee, former Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray. 

One of the more memorable phrases to come out of the speech is President Obama’s term “you’re on your own economics” to characterize the preferred economic plan of the GOP.  The contrast came with President Obama’s insistence that American prosperity, long-term prosperity, is gained together, in contrast to the “YoYo” economic ideas of the GOP. 

But President Obama’s speech led up to what I felt was the culminating point: illustrating for the American people that there is a different form of capitalism available; one that is more responsible and ultimately self-sustaining than the winner-take-all capitalism we’ve endured the past 30 years.  The President spoke of Marvin Windows, of Warroad, Minnesota, and described (skip to the last 7 or so minutes of the video clip to catch it) how the company has never laid off a single worker in its 100+ year history, despite enduring the Great Depression and the ongoing Great Recession.  How did Marvin achieve that feat?  Simple; through shared sacrifice from both the workforce and the management when times have been tough.  The President didn’t get into details, obviously, but his simple illustration of what could be summed up for the audience that change, true change, is within our grasp if we see each other as fellow citizens, and recognize that prosperity will be gained through helping each other out, rather than shorting each other constantly.  Responsible capitalism is what we ought to strive for, rather than a corporate ethos solely driven by the fiduciary responsibility to shareholders.

The President attacked inequality sharply, broadly, and directly, and proposed some new/old ideas to guide us out of the predicament we find ourselves in as a nation.  If it was a speech somewhat lacking in the soaring rhetoric of campaign Obama of 2008, the sober tone reflected the weighty concerns facing the man as President.  In time, I believe this speech will be seen to be a major one, where he describes the economic goalposts as they have been set for the past number of decades, and proposes that we, as a nation, make the effort to shift them back so that the goal is within the majority’s reach once again.  This speech sets the stage for the 2012 campaign, surely, but it also challenges Americans to greater collective achievements. 

I don’t normally watch presidential speeches, but this one had me riveted from the start.  I’ll give Greg Sargent the last word on this topic, the final paragraph of a typically insightful blog post on the speech:

Political scientists will tell you that individual speeches don’t matter; and that grand themes are very unlikely to supplant the direct experience of the economy as a motivator of voters. But we’ll be hearing these themes countless times between now and election day. And anyone who had hoped that Obama and Dems would make an unapologetically populist and moral case against inequality and economic injustice central to Campaign 2012 should be pretty pleased with what they heard today.

Monday, November 21, 2011

The #Occupy movement and the generations

Just a short note of gratitude and no small amount of incredulity at the cross-generational dialogues that have been fostered through and around the Occupy movement, which I and others view as largely a Millenial generation-driven thing.  I was just reading a well-done post by Charles B. Pierce at Esquire’s Politics Blog and noting his tone lamenting the political fecklessness of many of those from his generation now holding the reins of power:

How hard can this be? How hard is it to tell people to get angry at the people who really are making off with their country's wealth and their personal futures, especially when it's the god's honest truth? How hard is it to tell people that they are not the enemy, that to shoot pepper spray into the eyes of a college student is to spit in the eye of everyone else? Please do not hand me concerns for your "political viability." That makes you cowards. The protesters are doing the hard work. They're the ones living in a dozen tiny Argentinas all around this country. They're the ones getting beaten up and tortured, on TV, with chemical agents. They're the ones going to jail. All I'm asking is that you all have their backs, and all you have to do is get up and give a whole bunch of speeches saying so. Right now, they're pretty much out their on an island while empty charlatans like Newt Gingrich and prissy little shmoes like David Brooks are beating them over the head rhetorically, while the cops are more than happy — indeed, damned near gleeful — to do it in person.

Barney Frank wonders where the Occupiers were during the elections of 2010? Give them a politics worthy of their courage and they'll show up. This does not seem to me to be a difficult problem, but it does appear possibly to be the last chance for progressive politics for an awfully long time. You don't need an $850,000 contract to see that.

That second bolded sentence “Give them a politics worthy of their courage and they’ll show up” sounds like one of the best lines I’ve heard this year, for both its succinct razor-edge of truth, to its political astuteness.  This generation out protesting, my generation, is the one that greatly helped President Obama get elected.  We came out of the Bush era scarred (as I’ve noted previously) and looking for a change that Obama appeared to represent.  But more than that, he represented prudent judgment in correctly sizing up many of the true threats to our country (the undercutting of civil liberties domestically and human rights abroad, being cogent for me in particular) and, yes, a courage in his opposition to the Iraq War that was greatly lacking in the politics of those days, and even moreso today.  The reality of President Obama has been drastically different from the representation of Candidate Obama, but at the time, he showed a side of politics that people yearned for.  Show us courageous politicians taking stands that put them on the right side of popular sentiment, particularly in the face of a potential loss of big money campaign donors, and I bet my generation will show up.

So it is with that background in mind that I have been considering the amount of support I see and hear from older generations for the movement now sweeping America.  A close family member informed me that on her recent trip to New York she happened upon an Occupy Wall Street group at a public park (not Zuccotti, mind you) and was very impressed with the “human microphone” and the positive, steadfast energy the group displayed, despite it being an awful, rainy NYC November day.  The Facebook posts I see from Gen-Xers, Baby Boomers, and on up regarding the Occupy Movement evince a strong bond between the generations that I don’t think I’ve ever seen as clearly in my life. 

I had always feared that the elites’ plan to divide the entitlement program pie, and to set those of us in younger generations on a different retirement plan than our parents, threatened to separate the generations (which is probably the point!) and why you still hear many GOP candidates discussing giving young people the “option” of purchasing health savings accounts and the like.  The fact that we’re all working and saving towards a common fund, a common vision, means we’re all in it together, to some extent, despite the fact that the powers-that-be want all that locked-up Social Security and Medicare money to be released to the predations and speculations of Wall Street. 

But now, the elites have played their hand too far.  They’ve effectively united a strong bloc of people across the generations because, let’s face it, we’ve all been looted in some way or another.  We recognize a common enemy: the collusion between big business and big government that works to undercut our rights and to separate an already economically-stratified society into one where you have vastly different justice systems, depending on your standing and net worth (witness this egregious hit-and-run case from Colorado last year involving a “wealth manager” and a cyclist for a great/horrifying example).  There’s no justice for those on the top, but a harsh and exacting justice for those of us not at the top.  Witness the UC Davis pepper-spraying last Friday:

Glenn Greenwald’s take on the UC Davis situation adroitly points towards the larger issue at play in our society:

The UC-Davis Chancellor responsible for the pepper-spraying of her students, Linda Katehi, today went on Good Morning America and explained why she should not resign or otherwise be held accountable: “we really need to start the healing process and move forward.” On a radio program in the afternoon, she expanded on this view by saying: “We need to move on.” So apparently — yet again — the only way everyone can begin to “heal” and “move forward” is if everyone agrees that those in power with the greatest responsibility be fully shielded from any consequences and that their bad acts be simply forgotten. I wonder where she learned that justifying rationale?

We yearn for justice as a society.  The concept of justice embedded in the Constitution argues that those at the top and those at the bottom ought to be equal in the eyes of the law, and yet, the past decade has clearly shown how far our society has gotten from those founding principles.  Occupy, for all of its media-unfriendliness and potential to turn off the “median voter,” is a nascent attempt at reclaiming that original concept of justice.  Justice is anathema to the powers-that-be, as their gains are largely ill-gotten and their positions in society often depend on their being the the best operators within a system of legalized corruption.  The moment their hold on power slips, and they no longer control the levers of power and the judiciary, they will be subject to the comeuppance that has been long in coming, and much delayed. 

Greenwald quotes Rosa Luxemburg’s epic comment to wonderful effect:

“Those who do not move, do not notice their chains.”

If you look askance at the Occupy movement, and you see nothing but a bunch of rowdy young people lacking drive and ambition, ask yourself how you’re constrained in your own life.  What cutbacks have you had to make to your hopes and dreams, let alone your financial position?  How many of those setbacks are due entirely to your own poor judgment or over-extension, rather than being at least in part the shock wave from a system of willfully-created asset bubbles and legislatively-endorsed corruption imploding upon itself?  If you trace the origins of your own problems back to their logical starting points, do they solely originate from your decisions?  That is the line of thinking the powers-that-be hope you’ll take away.  Heaven forbid you should look up the food chain to discover how usury has been made legal and how student loans are no longer discharged in bankruptcy; how insolvent banks are allowed to claim the full face value of toxic assets to bolster their bottom lines, and yet how lying to get food stamps to feed one’s two children can net you 3 years in federal prison.  “Justice,” these days, comes at the expense of the rest of us.  We can see this fact in all its harsh reality and find a unity in it, or we can deny deny deny that the mirror the Occupy movement is holding up to our society reflects far more of our collective life experiences of brokenness and unnecessary misery than we’d care to admit. 

Thank you to those of the older generations who see the Occupy movement not as a threat, but as the opportunity for a rebirth.  We need you, and you need us.  We ARE in this together.

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

#OccupyWallStreet: The precursors to the occupations?

I was just reading Christina Romer’s very well-done piece in Sunday’s New York Times, making the case that announcing nominal GDP targeting should be the Federal Reserve’s next policy move (I encourage you to read the article for the details).  Here’s the key section I’d like to highlight:

HOW would this help to heal the economy? Like the Volcker money target, it would be a powerful communication tool. By pledging to do whatever it takes to return nominal G.D.P. to its pre-crisis trajectory, the Fed could improve confidence and expectations of future growth.

Such expectations could increase spending and growth today: Consumers who are more certain that they’ll have a job next year would be less hesitant to spend, and companies that believe sales will be rising would be more likely to invest.

--

Though announcing the new framework would help, it probably wouldn’t be enough to close the nominal G.D.P. gap anytime soon. The Fed would need to take additional steps. These might include further quantitative easing, more forceful promises about short-term interest rates, and perhaps moves to lower the exchange rate. Such actions wouldn’t just affect expectations; they would also be directly helpful. For example, a weaker dollar would stimulate exports.

How many of you reading this article feel that our government is “willing to do whatever it takes” to get us out of this persistent unemployment crisis, with all of its attendant suffering and economic misery?  I’d bet not a one of you – I certainly don’t think our government is trying its best to fix things.  Of course, it depends on how one defines “government” I suppose, but if you initially think of our elected branches, since we voters have the most direct control over the executive and the legislative, then no, the “government” in that sense is definitely not working on our behalf! 

And really, how ridiculous is it that the government of the wealthiest country that has ever existed can’t even act in a coordinated manner to stem the suffering of a massive segment of its population?  Or perhaps even more sinister, it appears that the government won’t act to stem the suffering.  Our elected officials have abdicated virtually any and all responsibility until after November 2012 in order to best position themselves politically and rhetorically for the electoral battles to come.  Sure the President is still hammering away on his newfound populist message, his “jobs proposal,” and is taking actions on behalf of homeowners, student loan borrowers, and prescription drug patients, among others, but let’s be honest folks, his track record on the “following-through-on-populist-sentiments” score ain’t that great…(see option, public for an example).

So now we face the absurd reality that the Federal Reserve, the quasi-governmental entity that is perhaps the least-democratic, most-opaque, and most removed from the basic economic reality of most Americans is being pushed to solve our jobs crisis through pure monetary policy.  The Federal Reserve has a dual mandate of preserving price stability as well as maintaining full employment, and the main critique of the Fed for many years has been that it has focused virtually exclusively on the former (in the form of interest rate targeting) while wholly neglecting the latter.  Despite the fact that it has been broadly apparent that allowing interest rates to rise somewhat would facilitate the creation of more jobs, the interest rate hawks within the Fed have consistently put a stop to any of those practices, warning of mythical “bond vigilantes” who will decide that US Treasuries are no longer worth investing in if the interest rate rises even a smidge, despite massive evidence to the contrary.  (The counterpoint, of course, is that investing in Treasuries represents the safest investment one can make in the troubled and volatile world markets, as while the state of the US debt and economy overall might cause debt holders concern if the rest of the world were in better shape, the relative position and strength of the US economy in the current world economy makes it a better investment vis a vis other sovereign bonds.)  But I digress.

Why are people occupying so many public spaces in so many cities across the United States and abroad?  I think it is precisely as a response to the massive systemic failure we’ve witnessed at all levels of our government to actually make a positive impact on the vast majority of Americans’ lives.  This is not to say that Americans en masse are waiting for government aid or action or anything like that, rather that the silliness we are witnessing playing out on Capitol Hill and in the White House, the constant tit-for-tat, is leading Americans to see their government as willfully sitting on its perfectly-capable hands, rather than deigning to lift a finger to tilt the scales of justice even minutely back on their side. 

A significant portion of these Occupiers likely played a large role in electing President Obama in 2008 – the sense of triumph in that election was not simply due to the historical nature of electing the first African-American president, but because Obama appeared to represent a turn of the page, or perhaps, a close of the book, from the utter depredation of the Bush Administration, hollowed out to a shell of itself in the end due to its sheer lack of competence.  Post-Katrina America had scars, deep scars affecting the national sense of whether the government was truly acting in our interests or not if it could bungle emergency management so completely. 

Obama represented a shift towards competence, towards smart folks who looked at the data to get things done and make decisions…and yet, after the health care debate, the pyrrhic victory of an apparent giveaway to the health insurance industry, combined with the Wall Street-friendly nature of the new Administration, and the declaration that many of the high-level prosecutions that many desired for actors both inside and outside of government were to be strictly off-limits by Obama and Attorney General Holder marked a certain continuity between the Bush and Obama Administrations: elites are coddled, bailed out, and constantly regaled, no matter their transgressions.  The little people, the 99%, have no place in this insular Washington-Wall Street-Pentagon calculus.

The election of Obama, in this narrative, represents not the shift, the hope, the change that people were hoping for, but the continuation of the perpetual insult to the nation’s sense of values and fairness – an insult that, prior to the rise of the Occupy movement was largely undefined and nameless for many Americans.  Guantanamo, Abu Ghraib, bank bailouts, auto bailouts, the death of the public option, no Wall Street prosecutions, no torture prosecutions, warrantless wiretapping, unmanned drone strikes on countries and civilians we aren’t at war with, wars that are declared against enemies that are largely undefined…whose heads roll for any of these awful decisions? 

The failure of our institutions, and the growing widespread understanding of that fact, as I alluded to a few weeks ago, and more obliquely, in the title of my last blog post “Don’t think it’s not bipartisan, it is,” is profoundly bipartisan.  It had to be to manifest itself so clearly to so many at just this point in time.  Just as you would likely not have a Tea Party had John McCain won, the nature of the Occupy movement, if it were to exist in an alternate world under a McCain Administration, would be very different to what we see today.  It took the failure of Obama, the landslide-elected change agent to bring justice, to bring accountability to the corrupt elites of this country, for the Occupy movement to spring up.  In this case, perhaps the Change that is thus far unrealized will be the catalyst for the realization of the true Change, whatever that may be. 

The bipartisan failure is a wholesale indictment of the entire construct of democracy in this country, and has likely soured many in the Millenial generation on the act of voting itself.  Perhaps democracy, as it is now constructed, is not in fact the method for enacting the change we wish to see in the world?  Could it be that the leverage points upon which the entrenched interests and powers can bring their influence to bear on candidates and nominating parties in our democratic system are simply too numerous and too porous?  The vast constellation of special interests funding candidates these days ensures the ascendance of a certain type of candidate: one who must be conversant in the ways of money, though preferably not “of” money (they’re easier to control with the promise of high-paying post public service jobs, you see) and who have hewn lines that conform to the dominant economic and social memes of the day, thus ensuring the continued preservation of the entrenched classes.  Any “change” will thus be marginal, minimal, the scraps thrown to those too poor to afford their own public affairs divisions or hired-gun lobbyists to press their case in the halls of power. 

Ultimately, though, it doesn’t matter whether Obama speaks the right words, or even whether he follows through on his newly populistic leanings with actual substantive legislative victories; the narrative is no longer his to drive, nor is it the GOP’s or the Tea Party’s.  They are reacting, all of them.  Consider:

Occupy Wall Street has already achieved a stunning victory – a victory that is easy to overlook, but impossible to overstate. In just one month, the protesters have shifted the national dialogue from a relentless focus on the deficit to a discussion of the real issues facing Main Street: the lack of jobs -- and especially jobs with decent benefits -- spiraling inequality, cash-strapped American families' debt-loads, and the pernicious influence of money in politics that led us to this point.

To borrow the loosely defined terms that define the Occupy movement, these ordinary citizens have shifted the conversation away from what the “1 percent” -- the corporate right and its dedicated media, network of think-tanks and PR shops -- want to talk about and, notably, paid good money to get us to talk about.

What were you reading about daily in the newspapers as recently as 6 weeks ago?  Austerity austerity austerity.  What did the Occupy movement bring to the table?  Non-manufactured talking points that actually speak to people.  Something you can bring home to your family and discuss at your kitchen table as a concept that everyone understands, intuitively.  Fair wages, decent jobs, non-criminal banks, supporting your neighbors and your community.  These are American values, no matter what the cable news pundits say who myopically search for the “demands” of the Occupy movement despite the hundreds and thousands of protest signs shouting demands right at them. 

People want a fair shake, for themselves, their children, their coworkers, their neighbors, their fellow churchgoers.  That’s pretty much all I’ve come up with, at the end of the day, and it’s pretty simple.  How we get to the fair shake for all is the more complicated problem.

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Don’t think it’s not bipartisan, it is

A Washington Post headline today that speaks volumes: Obama still flush with cash from financial sector despite frosty relations:

…Obama has brought in more money from employees of banks, hedge funds and other financial service companies than all the other GOP candidates combined, according to a Washington Post analysis of contribution data.

…Obama’s ties to Wall Street donors could complicate Democratic plans to paint Republicans as puppets of the financial industry, particularly in light of the Occupy Wall Street protests that have gone global over the past week. In response to the protests, the Obama campaign and other Democrats have stepped up their attacks on Romney and other Republicans for their opposition to Wall Street regulations.

One top banking executive who raises money for Obama and who requested anonymity to discuss fundraising efforts said reports of disaffection with the president “are exaggerated and overblown.” He said a strong contingent of financiers in New York, Chicago and California remain supportive of Obama and his economic policies, even as some have turned on him.

Now, all is not as it seems, as the Democratic National Committee has the ability to raise $30,800 per donor per year, whereas direct contributions to candidates’ campaign funds are capped at $5,000 per donor for the entire campaign cycle.  Because Obama is the Democratic nominee for president in 2012, he is able to coordinate fundraising with the DNC, whereas because the Republican primary is still underway, the RNC is not yet coordinating with a specific candidate.

That all being said, we’re still talking about vast sums of money here, with the election over a year away.  Is there not something troubling about that?


So yesterday I gave a bit of grief to Mitt Romney for being cold and calculating (or at least giving every impression that he is when it comes to the plight of homeowners) and I feel the need to point out that President Obama himself is certainly no stranger to financial industry largesse.  Wall Street gave more money to President Obama in 2008 than they did John McCain, and finance has remained a key part of the President’s fundraising arsenal since. 

Obama’s done an intricate dance with Big Finance since his inauguration, calling them “fat-cat bankers” and warning that his administration was “the only thing between you and the pitchforks” while appointing a very Wall Street-friendly Treasury Secretary in Tim Geithner, as well as a former VP of JP Morgan Chase as his latest Chief of Staff, Bill Daley, among other key players. 

It is true, on the other hand, that President Obama helped shepherd the Dodd-Frank financial regulations through to passage in Congress.  But the implementation process of such a complex bill has been met with delays in regulation writing and an apparent lack of gumption on the Administration’s part to support nominees to key oversight positions.  Why is Elizabeth Warren running for the US Senate in Massachusetts and not running the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which she effectively created whole cloth?  It’s due in major part to the Obama Administration’s not weighing in with more support for Warren against predictable Senate Republican intransigence in blocking her nomination.  The fight over securing Warren’s nomination would have been a titanic one, as the financial industry was as opposed to the creation of the CFPB as anything else in Dodd-Frank, and 44 Senate Republicans promised to block any nominee to the CFPB’s Directorship, not just Warren.  And yet, President Obama, despite what could have been a prime opportunity to highlight Republican tactics that negatively affect consumers, didn’t seem to have the fight in him on this one, for reasons still unknown.

A further area of concern has been the ongoing “50-state” Attorneys General housing settlement negotiations, which have sought to release the big banks from any liabilities for their criminal ways during the housing boom of the 00s in exchange for a paltry $20 billion or so in fines.  See the video below with Delaware Attorney General Beau Biden (son of Joe) giving a great overview of the major issues:

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Despite the appearance of massive fraud by every major bank, the Obama Administration has been pushing rather hard to have all 50 AGs sign on to the agreement, which is ostensibly narrowly related to the robosigning fraud unearthed last year, however the negotiated terms of the agreement attempt to release the banks from all sorts of liabilities unrelated to robosigning.  That a number of upright state AGs have stood up against such attempts to sweep illegal activities under the rug may not be terribly surprising, but that the Obama Administration would be aligning itself with the criminals in this case so blatantly certainly gives one pause.  Does Obama think promoting a less bank-friendly investigation might hurt his fundraising opportunities with Wall Street?  Such a consideration can’t be far from the top of his mind…When Obama’s reelection is going to be fought against a GOP that still considers wholesale deregulation to be a viable job creation strategy despite all evidence to the contrary, he has to give Big Finance some carrots to keep their contributions flowing to his coffers, no?


And that’s the crux of the problem.  That’s what Occupy Wall Street is about – the failure of institutions to offer any alternative to the rampant corruption that is right before all of our eyes.  There is no alternative to the current system, and no viable way to use “democracy” to achieve the real change that people appear to seek, as the votes are rigged in favor of the winners.  Justice itself is being undercut systematically so that those who have won historically can keep right on winning, consequences be damned.  It’s no way to run a country.

For his part, Obama has presided over a time that has been marked by major investigations and public exposures of unbelievably bad behavior and rampant greed among the elites who run the economy; a time where an average citizen can find any number of things to be unspeakably outraged about.  Obama’s time in office has coincided with a loss of trust in institutions that would have happened with or without his being President.  And yet, it behooves me to ask how much he himself has contributed to the loss of trust Americans feel in their government?  Sure he inherited a bad situation from his predecessor, but where has he exacerbated the structural problems in our society with his choices?  I’ve been attempting to map out some of the terrain where I feel there has been a governmental failure on this blog for some time now; not because I am opposed to our President, far from it.  It is because so much of the government’s response to issues of structural criminality have been to mask those issues, to sweep them under the rug, to choose not to act in the face of injustice in the hopes that the average low-information voter will not pick up on that act of collusion.  Obama or no, I won’t stand for that.

I believe in a better, stronger, more just and more free America – I have to believe in it; I’m a member of the generation that will be picking up the pieces when those in power today have long departed from the scorched earth they are rapidly creating in their wake.  I believe that we can have a government that works on behalf of the people, and I intend to do my part to make that happen.  But when the government is itself an impediment to the realization of those goals, when it uses its might and state secrets privileges and its power to regulate (or not) in the service of those who would bend government to their own nefarious ends, I feel the need to call attention to those acts as a lowly scribe/blogger. 

I have a proposal in the works that will present a more positive vision for the future, that will present some concrete actions individuals can take to change their own lives as well as their communities for the better, and I sincerely hope to present it on this blog soon.  This blog, in the attempt at chronicling so much wrongdoing, has taken on a terribly negative tone, and I hope to change that in the very near future.

Thanks for reading, as always, and stay tuned.

P.S. – Here’s a great read from Charles P. Pierce of Esquire, taking on Romney’s callous discussion of foreclosures and the curveball that the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts threw his way today.  Great fun, or not.

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

We are here (#OccupyWallStreet)

Apologies for the extended radio silence (almost a full year since the last post, in fact.)  Blame finishing up graduate school, getting married this summer, and starting a new job recently.  All wonderful, joyous life-events; I am blessed.

So what’s changed in our world since November 2, 2010?  Anything much?

h/t Mike Konczal

Chances are you may have heard about the Occupy Wall Street protests currently going on in New York.  At the risk of opening myself to later ridicule if suddenly the occupation falls apart and nothing more comes of it, I believe that these protests happening all over the country are the start of something new (and yet quite certainly old) in our political/social/economic discourse.  The Occupation is, in the very broadest sense of the term, a great showing of people power. 

What have these protesters done?  They have reclaimed, at least in miniature, a part of the commons: those public spaces that are free and open for all to use.  They have reclaimed Zuccotti Park (renamed Liberty Park by the occupiers) and are holding it, occupying it by the simple act of gathering together en masse, in an ad hoc community of equals.  In the midst of the most powerful globalizing force in this world, the colossus that bestrides the world through its use and abuse of capital in pursuit of more capital, Wall Street, the occupiers have recreated a locality, a community of human persons, rather than corporate persons.  The physical act of being is, perhaps, the means and the end of their protest; the thumb in the eye of those who would subjugate others to modern debt peonage by a systematic deindustrialization, de-unionization, debasement of those who were at one point hopeful and perhaps even comfortable in their lives. 

h/t JW Mason

This protest, the fact that people from all walks of life feel that the most effective method of expressing their outrage is a purposely undefined and undirected occupation of a public space, reflects the profound disillusionment in and failure of institutions in our society.  Business, government, the media, various levels of education, healthcare…somehow all of these institutions have conspired to make Americans’ lives collectively far worse than they have been at any time in recent memory. 

For some elucidation of this point, at least in part, witness the media’s sudden interest in Occupy Wall Street, despite the ostensible lack of media savviness in the occupiers’ ranks.  Much of the media coverage has focused on the lack of a coherent message from the occupiers, or attempts to fit OWS into accepted “protest paradigms;” witness this sad example of both at once:

A question was asked of me yesterday about the Occupy Wall Street movement that has been a presence in lower Manhattan since Sept. 17. Are there any parallels between it and the Tea Party movement? Yes. But if it doesn’t do four things — 1.) broaden its base of support to include those who share its values or goals; 2.) get specific about what the goals are; 3.) bring the protests to Washington; and 4.) get support from members of Congress — it could squander its momentum.

I have problems with all four of the author’s points he makes, but I’d like to draw out what I see as the overall tone of this response – bring it to Washington or it doesn’t exist.  Present the powers-that-be with a specific set of legislative goals you’d like to achieve and let them VOTE on them; that’s how you define and achieve success.

This movement does not fit into the left-right paradigm that is necessary for the media to comprehend it, except to the extent that in many of the occupiers’ state opinions, re-establishing some semblance of justice in this country tends to require what are considered “liberal” policy responses.  BOTH parties in this country are bought off by the money machine, enabled by our Supreme arbiters of justice, for whom speech and money are equivalent in the political sphere (thus ensuring that those with more money by definition have more “speech”).  Washington is a morass of corruption, legalized.  When politicians say that Washington is “broken,” they simply mean that their political donors are not able to extract as much legislated wealth as before due to the gridlock that is currently wracking our nation’s political process.  What OWS is saying with their physical presence is that yes, Washington is broken, and it’s time to clean house and re-establish the norms so that they work for all, not just those at the top.  The failure is bipartisan in nature:

Occupy Wall Street and its spin-offs have found little support so far among Democrats, outside of a few lawmakers on the left of the party.
“The message of Occupy Wall Street is we think both political parties are owned by the same guys,” said David Graeber, a former professor of anthropology at Yale who joined in the protests. “If democracy is to mean anything, it means that everybody has to weigh in on this process of how money is created and promises are renegotiated.”

Democratic politicians don’t want to upset their precious campaign donors, so they stay studiously away from the most authentic outpouring of the populism that their party claims to represent in years.  That fact exemplifies the outsized role of money in our politics – if you hew to the party line, you get campaign bucks; if you deviate, we take it away and give it to your opponent, simple as that.

What will this Occupation come to in the end?  Who knows?  I am thankful it is occurring though, and I will have more to say about this topic in coming days.  Where do you stand?  Support or oppose?

Thursday, October 14, 2010

The foreclosure fraud mess – a day of reckoning at last?

Foreclosure Message The foreclosure fraud case is one of the BIG stories I’ve been trying my best to follow lately.  We learned today that all 50 state Attorneys General have opened an investigation into mortgage industry practices:

The state attorneys general are looking at allegations some banks did not properly review files or submitted false statements to evict delinquent borrowers from their homes during a foreclosure crisis that is one of the most visible wounds of the 2007-2009 recession.

"We are in the fourth year of a housing and economic crisis that was brought on by lax practices of the mortgage lending industry," Minnesota Attorney General Lori Swanson said in a statement.

"The latest allegations of corner-cutting and slipshod paperwork are troubling, but perhaps not surprising."

--

The states are investigating the use of "robo-signers" -- people who sign hundreds of affidavits a day -- by banks and companies that collect monthly mortgage payments. It is alleged they did not properly review the documents they were signing.

"What we have seen are not mere technicalities, as some suggest," Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray said.

So if there was systematic fraud perpetrated throughout the mortgage lending industry, one would hope we’d finally see some of these scoundrels locked up for awhile. 

Incidentally, one of the last times that all 50 state Attorneys General agreed to pursue a coordinated investigation, guess what the alleged crime was?  Predatory lending.  And guess who took the lead in making the public case for the investigation – then-Governor of New York Eliot Spitzer.  Spitzer came out swinging against the mortgage lending industry and the banks at large in a February 14, 2008 Washington Post piece that is worth excerpting from at length (but well worth a read in its entirety):

Several years ago, state attorneys general and others involved in consumer protection began to notice a marked increase in a range of predatory lending practices by mortgage lenders. Some were misrepresenting the terms of loans, making loans without regard to consumers' ability to repay, making loans with deceptive "teaser" rates that later ballooned astronomically, packing loans with undisclosed charges and fees, or even paying illegal kickbacks. These and other practices, we noticed, were having a devastating effect on home buyers. In addition, the widespread nature of these practices, if left unchecked, threatened our financial markets.

Even though predatory lending was becoming a national problem, the Bush administration looked the other way and did nothing to protect American homeowners. In fact, the government chose instead to align itself with the banks that were victimizing consumers.

--

Let me explain: The administration accomplished this feat through an obscure federal agency called the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC). The OCC has been in existence since the Civil War. Its mission is to ensure the fiscal soundness of national banks. For 140 years, the OCC examined the books of national banks to make sure they were balanced, an important but uncontroversial function. But a few years ago, for the first time in its history, the OCC was used as a tool against consumers.

In 2003, during the height of the predatory lending crisis, the OCC invoked a clause from the 1863 National Bank Act to issue formal opinions preempting all state predatory lending laws, thereby rendering them inoperative. The OCC also promulgated new rules that prevented states from enforcing any of their own consumer protection laws against national banks. The federal government's actions were so egregious and so unprecedented that all 50 state attorneys general, and all 50 state banking superintendents, actively fought the new rules. (emphasis mine)

The Bush Administration intervened to stop the states from investigating and enforcing their own predatory lending laws, which I think just might qualify as an egregious breach of the sacredness of “states’ rights” in GOP doctrine, eh?

But as we all now know, hubris brought Spitzer’s gubernatorial reign down (but he’s not out, have you seen him on CNN recently?) with the high-priced call girl scandal he was ensnared in just a few weeks after he wrote his Valentine’s Day article.  Let me make a quick aside at this point and say in no uncertain terms that I am not arguing that what Spitzer did was by any means acceptable.  Now, that being said, could there be any coincidence between his article broadcasting the Bush Administration’s outrageous actions on behalf of predatory lenders and his being outed as a john?  Let’s look a bit further:

Spitzer's fall was all the more stunning because he had been elected in November 2006 with 69 percent of the vote, the most ever in a New York gubernatorial race, and some Democrats even said he could possibly become the country's first Jewish president.

But his life and career began unraveling last week, when federal agents, acting on wiretaps, busted a high-class New Jersey-based prostitution ring, called Emperors Club VIP, and arrested four people. The criminal complaint listed an anonymous "Client 9," who was heard calling the escort service to arrange for a call girl named "Kristen" to meet him for a Feb. 13 tryst at Washington's Mayflower Hotel.

The client allegedly paid for the woman's train fare from New York to Washington and $4,300 for a two-hour session. Law enforcement sources confirmed this week that Client 9 was Spitzer.

--

There are also questions about the identities of the other wealthy clients of the Emperors Club VIP. The criminal complaint unsealed last week made reference to 10 clients without naming them; only Spitzer has been identified as Client 9. (all emphases mine)

Interesting that Spitzer was the only client whose name was leaked identified to the press, especially because he was later cleared of all charges:

The details of Mr. Spitzer’s financial transactions — how he took money from his personal accounts and sent it to the prostitution ring’s front company, QAT International — were always the crucial questions in the case. Prosecutors, from the start, were trying to determine whether there was ample evidence to charge Mr. Spitzer with a crime called structuring, which makes it illegal to conduct financial transactions in a way intended to conceal their source and purpose.

Michael Horowitz, another former chief of the public corruption unit in Manhattan, said that it was rare for prosecutors to pursue a structuring charge without a substantive underlying crime like money laundering or drug trafficking. He suggested that a prostitution case, which the government was unlikely to prosecute anyway, was not enough to undergird a structuring charge. (emphasis mine)

So the government knew that Spitzer’s crimes were not going to lead him to prison, and yet it is uncommon for sitting politicians involved in sex scandals to be forced out of office, look at South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford, US Senator from Nevada John Ensign, and US Senator from Louisiana David Vitter (who was also caught in a prostitution scandal – the DC Madam case).  None of them were forced out of their jobs; do the rules bend when Republicans are involved, or was Spitzer more the exception to the rule in being forced out?  And why does it appear that some people in high places decided to drop the axe on Spitzer to muzzle him just after he publicly charged that the Bush Administration aided and abetted predatory lenders?

That line of questioning leads us back to the now-unfolding foreclosure fraud situation, explained in great detail here by Mike Konczal of the Roosevelt Institute.  The banks, as we all are well aware, benefited from a massive infusion of taxpayer largess in the form of the bailout (TARP) of October 2008 (remember it was Bush’s bailout folks, no matter what the Tea Party may wrongly claim) and that the bailouts served to rehabilitate a good chunk of the banks’ balance sheets.  But the banks still were forced to contend with the problem of widespread despair in the housing markets, and with the fact that many of the houses that they owned were, in fact, overvalued assets due to the nationwide plunge in home values. 

Because the banks have gotten “too-big-to-fail” (which is what necessitated the bailouts in the first place) as I’ve discussed in a previous posting at length, the government has continued to help prop the banks up, lest the entire financial apparatus collapse entirely.  Programs such as the Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP) that are ostensibly designed to incentivize banks to help homeowners renegotiate their mortgages on more favorable terms, have been shown to serve the banks’ interests entirely.  From a report by Steve Waldman on a meeting Geithner and other top Treasury officials had with financial bloggers over the summer:

The conversation next turned to housing and HAMP. On HAMP, officials were surprisingly candid. The program has gotten a lot of bad press in terms of its Kafka-esque qualification process and its limited success in generating mortgage modifications under which families become able and willing to pay their debt. Officials pointed out that what may have been an agonizing process for individuals was a useful palliative for the system as a whole. Even if most HAMP applicants ultimately default, the program prevented an outbreak of foreclosures exactly when the system could have handled it least. There were murmurs among the bloggers of “extend and pretend”, but I don’t think that’s quite right. This was extend-and-don’t-even-bother-to-pretend. The program was successful in the sense that it kept the patient alive until it had begun to heal. And the patient of this metaphor was not a struggling homeowner, but the financial system, a.k.a. the banks. Policymakers openly judged HAMP to be a qualified success because it helped banks muddle through what might have been a fatal shock. I believe these policymakers conflate, in full sincerity, incumbent financial institutions with “the system”, “the economy”, and “ordinary Americans”. Treasury officials are not cruel people. I’m sure they would have preferred if the program had worked out better for homeowners as well. But they have larger concerns, and from their perspective, HAMP has helped to address those. (all emphases mine)

There you go, policymakers playing kabuki with taxpayers in order to help keep the banks who got us into this mess alive…what a grotesque situation!

And yet, after all of this has happened, some are saying, like former financial executive RJ Eskow, that the foreclosure fraud scandal may just show that the emperor (the banks in this case) has no clothes:

The foreclosure fraud scandal is a big deal (or a big "effin'" deal, as Joe Biden might say). But its real significance is an even bigger deal. Foreclosure fraud is one domino, and if it falls others will follow. The result could be an end to the "invisible bailout" -- the one you never hear about, the one that forces millions of people to subsidize bad lending practices in order to prop up Wall Street.

The invisible bailout is the reason why the government isn't pushing to freeze foreclosures. If the foreclosure process is halted and lending practices are thoroughly investigated, it might eventually force bankers to own up to their own lawlessness -- and write down billions of dollars in artificially inflated assets. How are they going to pay themselves record bonuses if that happens?

This is where it gets really ugly – our somewhat/perhaps/maybe/kinda recovering economy could well be plunged into another, perhaps deeper financial downturn if widespread fraud is in fact found among the banks’ mortgages.  If nobody knows who rightfully holds the title to a home, how could they possibly know its market value?  The entire financial system has been rebuilt (if one could even call it that) after the 2008 financial crisis on a foundation of nearly worthless and potentially fraudulent mortgages, and “irresponsible homeowners” have been to blame for not only their own troubles, but those of the entire financial system.  Eskow continues:

Nobel prizewinner Joseph Stiglitz, who also bears the distinction of having been correct about the housing bubble, thinks it's time for the banks to write down the excess value of these loans. As Stiglitz observes, that will be painful for the banks in the short term, although it would be "nothing in comparison to the suffering they have inflicted on people throughout the rest of the global economy."

But the administration's reluctant to do that. That's why we heard such tepid remarks from the White House about the foreclosure fraud scandal over the weekend. If the foreclosure fraud issue is pursued too aggressively, it throws 41% of all expected housing sales into question. It raises even more questions about the ownership of millions of loans in good standing, potentially giving homeowners leverage to renegotiate based on the actual market value of their homes. And it reopens the issue of "writedowns."

Illegal submission of foreclosure documents was part of a larger cover-up. People need to be arrested for it -- but that, of course, would open up a larger can of worms. The legal process could very well reveal the extent of the title problem, as well as other potentially widespread criminal practices.

So there you have it folks, the states are now going after the big Wall Street fish again, perhaps following up on the forestalled investigations they were set to launch back in 2003 when all of this mortgage madness could have been nipped in the bud.  In case you are in any doubt about just what was produced by the collusion between government and Wall Street, Ezra Klein interviewed financial analyst Janet Tavakoli last week, and here’s her response when being asked what this all means for the banks (after calling this crisis “the biggest fraud in the history of the capital markets”):

When we had the financial crisis, the first thing the banks did was run to Congress and ask for accounting relief. They asked to be able to avoid pricing this stuff at the price where people would buy them. So no one can tell you the size of the hole in these balance sheets. We’ve thrown a lot of money at it. TARP was just the tip of the iceberg. We’ve given them guarantees on debts, low-cost funding from the Fed. But a lot of these mortgages just cannot be saved. Had we acknowledged this problem in 2005, we could’ve cleaned it up for a few hundred billion dollars. But we didn’t. Banks were lying and committing fraud, and our regulators were covering them and so a bad problem has become a hellacious one. (emphases mine)

As Eskow said above, the bankers just want to make it seem that they’ve actually produced some semblance of profits for their shareholders so they can continue to collect their exorbitant bonuses.  That greed leads the bankers to convince regulators to help them avoid realizing the losses they should rightfully incur for such terrible investments.  That dynamic then leads to continued uncertainty in the market, which causes the banks not to lend to businesses, individuals, or even to each other. Greed has never run so rampant in the streets, and it is now manifestly clear that it is the greed of the privileged few that is genuinely handcuffing any sort of economic recovery for the rest of us.  Government regulators have bought into this system for years – when Eliot Spitzer began to make a stink, he was publicly disgraced and muzzled quickly, lest his accusations about the rotting core of the financial system lead people to look too closely so that the house of cards fell. 

Government has been complicit in this scheme since day one, which is the real reason none of the fraudsters have been put in prison yet – the circle would likely extend too widely and might ensnare some of those who are supposed to be on the “good” team.  We can’t have change in this country until we have an honest accounting of the mistakes of the past, and I surely hope that the state Attorneys General are allowed to run their investigations as they see fit, with no White House interference.  The President’s actions in confronting this crisis, including the actions of his deputies, will show just how committed to change he really is. 

Monday, May 10, 2010

The future of finance?

My schedule has not permitted me to post anything fully-developed for quite a while, but tonight I have a few multimedia treats for you, building off of the news themes of recent weeks.

First off, "Quants, The Alchemists of Wall Street."  A film made about the mathematical geniuses who created the models that have been largely running the financial world for a number of years now.  While that may not sound like the most interesting subject matter, I highly recommend taking 45 minutes and watching the film, there's lots to learn:



I thought this was an interesting little film as it stood, however the second half takes a surprisingly prescient turn in that the interviewees (or "quants," short for "quantitative thinkers," I assume) begin to discuss "high frequency trading," a term that sprang into the wider international consciousness following last Thursday's as-yet-unexplained 1,000 point drop in the Dow.  The idea of high frequency trading (or HFT) is that arrays of computers are set up to catch any variations in a stock's price that exceed or fall below certain parameters, or that follow Google search terms and will buy or sell stocks based on what's "hot" on Google at that moment.  Those parameters are set by mathematical models created by quants.

There are a host of scary implications that result from high frequency trading (not least of which is that these computers essentially set up parallel market structures that operate outside of public scrutiny) however there is a somewhat more mundane detail that the film raised that I'd like to focus on.

One of the quants notes that the NYSE is going to be (or perhaps already has by this point) setting up a warehouse in New Jersey that will house huge arrays of computers, each belonging to the various financial firms, where they will engage in further HFT.  The idea is that the computers will be closer to the NYSE than before, and therefore they will have a faster data connection to the stock market.  A further implication is that certain firms will get "privileged" connections that will afford them a tenth of a second advantage over the other firms; how those firms are chosen, be it through lottery or through financial transactions with the NYSE (read: bribes), is unclear.

There are certain industries in the world that are capital-intensive, in the sense that those industries required a large amount of resources, be it money, physical inputs, or large areas of land, to operate.  Steel is a capital-intensive industry, as is telecommunications, which requires the development of a significant amount of infrastructure to operate.  Clearly the world of finance is a capital-intensive industry, as a firm generally requires large amounts of money to operate, however "boutique firms" have always existed that were able to operate with smaller amounts of cash.  With this impending shift to a computer- and geographically-dominated business model, I wonder if finance is becoming more capital-intensive too?

Consider that if you're a small player, you're going to be forever outmaneuvered by the big firms who have prime locations for the fastest connections for their computer servers in New Jersey, plus offices full of top-quality quants figuring out the most accurate (or at least, the least wrong) algorithms that are then fed into the computer systems constantly.  How is a small firm supposed to compete against that?  This sort of situation can only lead to further consolidation of the financial sector into fewer firms controlling more of the wealth in this country.  As I discussed in my previous post, further consolidation of wealth is a very bad thing indeed.
__________________________________________________________________________________

And now for something only slightly different...

A further interesting implication of the film was the concept put forth by a couple of the quants that economists in recent years have begun to regard themselves as "scientists;" that their models predicting financial market movements and concepts were "laws" that would be proven correct no matter the circumstances.  This, despite the fact that economics has, since its inception, been considered to be one of the social sciences, these economists who were running the world of finance believed themselves to be masters of the financial universe.

There is a small problem with the underpinnings of these economists' views of the world, however: humans are messy.  To the extent that any sort of "science" is based on looking at human behavior in the aggregate there will always be room for inputs that simply break one's perfectly-calibrated model of the world.  So to the extent that finance is based off of the actions of many individual stock traders and firms run by financiers, perhaps it, too, should be considered a social science?  At least the world of theoretical finance, such as the world in which these quants operated should be, as they're modeling human actions in the aggregate, much in the same way that economists do.  Therefore, as even the quants recognize in the film, their models may not have failed, but the ways that the models were used and manipulated by the non-quant stock traders to make money is at least one part of what contributed to the financial meltdown in 2008.  Humans are unpredictable, and while it's a valiant effort to try to model human behavior, the more I read and the more I learn, the more futile, ultimately, I think it may be.  Just a small observation...

__________________________________________________________________________________

Finally tonight, the terrible, terrible story of what happens when the financial markets run out of subprime mortgages to invest in: they turn to "commodities."  Commodities markets trade derivatives of actual, physical goods, such as corn/maize futures, oil futures, or gold.  I don't wish to get into how the derivatives contracts work (partly because this post is already long enough and partly due to the fact that they're bloody complicated) but suffice it to say that firms betting on the futures markets can drive the prices of commodities up in a way that is completely unrelated to the underlying supply and demand fundamentals of that commodity.  Witness the continued high price of oil despite the fact that oil consumption is the lowest its been in years (see the link above for more on that).

These effects can be devastating for the poor and middle classes around the world, and sadly, the financial reform bills currently being debated in the Senate may do little to nothing to halt the devastation.

For Rounds 2 and 3 of the feature films tonight, I bring you an interview with Indian economist Jayati Ghosh, who explains to us that when finance gets its hands on the very food you seek to feed your family with, prices often will go up, to everyone's detriment.  This interview will infuriate you, and you'll want to yell at your computer screen "how can humans be so immoral as to create food bubbles and starve the poor???"  Well having seen "Quants" now, and gaining a bit of access into the mind of the modern financial mathematician, I can see, to an extent, how that might happen.  When you're dealing only in abstract numbers, looking for the most promising market to invest in, with no concept of the fact that your actions will increase the price of corn to be used for tortillas in the slums of Mexico, then it's very easy to buy into that bubble.  Does modern finance add any social value to our society?  It's really hard to tell these days, but I guarantee I'll come back to that theme.

Part 1:


Part 2:


I have been working on more complex postings having to do with the nature of the financial/political nexus that has developed and subsumed our political life in this country, and I hope to post those soon.  Furthermore, the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico and the Greek debt crisis are all fodder for future postings, if there's time...

Friday, April 16, 2010

The Continuing Scourge of Too Big To Fail

WASHINGTON -  APRIL 9:  In this handout image ...Image by Getty Images via Daylife
I had the distinct pleasure of hearing Simon Johnson, an economist and professor of entrepreneurship at MIT's Sloan School of Business (and former Chief Economist for the International Monetary Fund) speak last night at a wonderful event produced by Zocalo Public Square, a local LA non-profit public affairs forum.  Johnson also is the author (with James Kwak) of the recently published 13 Bankers, about the financial crisis and how to stop another crisis from occurring again, and blogs at the Baseline Scenario, a blog I've been following for months and have linked to several times previously.

Johnson spoke quite emphatically about the need for fundamental financial reform, not as a partisan of any stripe (indeed, he claims to be a free-marketer more than anything else) but because the current financial system we have is not actually "capitalism" per se.  Why is that?  Well the phrase "too big to fail" (TBTF) signifies the problem at the center of our financial crisis, and within TBTF lies the potentiality for a future crisis even larger than the current one.  

First of all, what is "too big to fail"?  While we've certainly all heard the term bandied about since September 2008, I imagine there is some confusion out there.  The concept is that the financial institutions that were bailed out through the Troubled Assets Relief Program (TARP) instituted by former Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson, Federal Reserve Chair Ben Bernanke, and President Bush, among others, simply held too many assets in our economy, and were too interconnected, to be allowed to declare bankruptcy.  If the financial institutions (banks, such as Bank of America, and investment houses, such as Goldman Sachs) were allowed to fail, as Lehman Brothers was, then those failures would lead to an unprecedented breakdown of the global financial markets.  Furthermore, due to the interconnectedness of the various players in the markets, the thinking goes, the failure of one of the financial institutions could lead to the failure of others.  Why the institutions were all so interconnected is perhaps beyond the scope of what I'd like to say here today (in interests of length), but suffice it to say that AIG is one of the primary sources of the interconnectedness, and Goldman Sachs is another.

How did we get to this point where the banks were so big and interconnected that they could not fail without bringing down the global economy?  Well, I could try to explain, but I think I'll let Prof. Johnson explain, with the help of Steven Colbert:

The Colbert ReportMon - Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c
Simon Johnson
www.colbertnation.com
Colbert Report Full EpisodesPolitical HumorFox News

Prof. Johnson raises a few points that are worth elucidating in that segment; first of all, the idea that the TBTF banks have an incentive to act recklessly and to take foolish risks with their investors' money.  This concept is known in economics terms as "moral hazard," and is essentially the idea that if you have a guarantee that the risks you face have been either eliminated or severely reduced by another party, then you will be inclined to take larger risks than you would without that guarantee.  Take, for instance, driving a car without auto insurance versus driving with auto insurance; you're likely to drive far more slowly and carefully without insurance than you would with insurance, because with your insurer's guarantee that they'll pick up any financial losses you incur through poor driving, you are not "on the hook" for your mistakes in the same way you would be without insurance.

The implicit backing of the government that came with the TARP bailouts of the largest financial sector players creates a moral hazard scenario in just the same way.  If a TBTF investment firm received a government bailout, then the individual managers and employees at that firm will be liable to take risks that they would not otherwise, as whatever they do, the government will ensure that their poor decisions don't cause the firm to go bust.  So, far from reducing the incentives of financial firms to reduce their exposure to risky investments, the bailouts in fact increased the incentives of firms to take massive risks, and to leave taxpayers to foot the bill.

A second point to discuss that is a corollary to the first (and which Johnson spoke at length about last night) is that the TBTF firms, with their implicit government backing, are receiving preferential treatment in the financial markets that are creating advantages for the banks to become even larger.  Essentially, because the government will not allow the TBTF firms to fail, they receive reduced interest rates when borrowing from private lenders.  Because the lenders perceive the TBTF firms as "safer" investments than firms that don't have government backing, they are willing to reduce the interest rates they charge the TBTF firms compared to other firms.  Naturally, this situation distorts the market's functioning, and gives the TBTF firms an advantage over their competitors that allows them to gain even larger market shares.  Hence, the failure of capitalism due to government intervention in the marketplace.  Johnson estimated the interest rates of the TBTF firms were reduced by approximately .7-.9% compared to their non-TBTF competitors, which may not sound like much, but when applied to loans and trades of billions of dollars at a time, those fractions of percents add up to large sums of money.  

So what is Prof. Johnson's solution?  To break up the TBTF firms into smaller, more manageable (and less economically dangerous) firms.  Johnson and a number of other significant economists estimate that a $100 billion limit on total assets under a firm's control is an ideal target to aim for.  What does that figure mean?  Well the current combined holdings of Bank of America, JP Morgan Chase, Citigroup, and Wells Fargo are approximately $7.4 trillion, and there are 23 institutions in the US that have assets over $100 billion.  Therefore, there will have to be a lot of division of these large institutions into smaller ones (simple arithmetic reveals that the $7.4 trillion of the four megabanks noted above, if divided into $100 billion sub-banks, would create 74 new institutions) and it is in the process of "breaking up" the banks that a lot of complication will occur, as in any complex transaction.  Furthermore, these firms are all multi-national, meaning that the US acting alone will not achieve any significant regulatory reforms unless those reforms are accompanied by international agreements.  It will be difficult enough for Congress to pass any semblance of meaningful financial reform (as evidenced by the Republicans' continued obstinacy) without having to deal with cross-border issues as well.  

I think I'll stop there for now.  There is still lots more to discuss about the financial crisis, as my understanding of the causes and the (proposed) solutions has been growing and evolving rapidly in recent months, and I'm eager to share what I've gained with you, my readers.  Despite not being a "finance guy" in the least, I believe that the simple fact that our financial sector has become such an integral part of the world economy requires that I attempt to understand what happened and how to prevent a recession of similar scale from ever happening again.  Any understanding I gain I'll attempt to pass on, since it's such a complex topic, but worthy of understanding by many.

In this posting I've focused only on the TBTF firms and the threats they pose to the financial markets and the world economy.  In future postings, I'll look at the political implications of such concentrations of wealth and power, as well as how it is that the financial sector got to have such power and influence as it does today.  If you have any further questions or a need for clarifications (or if I've totally bungled some facts in this posting) please comment on this piece below, or email me at generationalnavelgazing -at- gmail dot com (trying to protect my account from spammers, you know).

Additional programming note: I plan on returning to the subject of the Tea Party movement soon in an additional posting following up on my post from two weeks ago, so stay tuned for that.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

America's Endangered Middle Class


I just wanted to share this very powerful piece by Elizabeth Warren, chair of the Congressional Oversight Panel that is overseeing the banking bailouts (TARP). In it, she argues (with graphs, no less, a rarity in the blogosphere) that the middle class is, and has been, getting an extremely unfair deal in American society. Meanwhile, the bankers whom we bailed out from having to face the consequences of their own greed, are earning record profits this year and are on track to hand out massive bonuses, all in the name of "employee retention." To protest against this condition, this blatant unfairness at the intersection of American finance and government policy, is to be labeled a populist. Screw that, I'd rather be a populist standing up for the values of fair play that this country was founded upon than a Wall Street sycophant masquerading in elected office any day.

Thank you, Elizabeth Warren, for daring to speak truth to the powers-that-be in the Washington-Wall Street nexus.